Longevity myths

Contents

Longevity myths are traditions about long-lived people (generally supercentenarians), either as individuals or groups of people, and practices that have been believed to confer longevity, but for which scientific evidence does not support the ages claimed or the reasons for the claims.[1][2]

The phrase "longevity tradition" may include "purifications, rituals, longevity practices, meditations, and alchemy"[3] that have been believed to confer greater human longevity, especially in Chinese culture.[1][2]

Modern science indicates that genetics may exert a more powerful influence than diet or life style. Research into longevity suggests that it tends to run in families, and so may be linked to specific inherited genes.

Categorization

In fall 1955, Guinness World Records began maintaining a list of the verified oldest people that developed into a list of all supercentenarians that had been verified with three documents in a standard process. Unverified cases ("claims" or "traditions") that have not been controverted by reliable sources vary widely in their plausibility as determined by reliable demographic data. While no firm distinction exists, cases with complete birthdates and deathdates, or with last updates within the Guinness era, are easier to present in tabular format, while incomplete cases last updated prior to fall 1955 are easier to present in narrative format (below).

An essay appearing in many editions of Guinness World Records in the 1980s lists four categories of recent claims: "In late life, very old people often tend to advance their ages at the rate of about 17 years per decade .... Several celebrated super-centenarians (over 110 years) are believed to have been double lives (father and son, relations with the same names or successive bearers of a title) .... A number of instances have been commercially sponsored, while a fourth category of recent claims are those made for political ends ...."[4] Guinness implies other (historical) categories of longevity traditions to exist as well; this distinction is elaborated in more detail in Lucian Boia's 2004 book Forever Young: A Cultural History of Longevity from Antiquity to the Present. Both Arthur Custance[5] and demographers Jacques Vallin and France Meslé[6] make this distinction explicit, drawing a direct comparison and contrast of "longevity in antiquity" (the genealogies of Genesis) with "longevity in historical times" (common-era cases through twentieth-century news reports), though with differing conclusions. Actuary Walter G. Bowerman states that longevity assertions originate mainly in remote, underdeveloped regions, among illiterate peoples, evidenced by nothing more than family testimony.[7] Longevity traditions may also include "purifications, rituals, longevity practices, meditations, and alchemy"[3] that have been believed to confer greater human longevity, especially in Chinese culture.[1][2]

Cases in mythology, religion and literature

Sumer

Age claims for the earliest eight Sumerian kings in the major recension of the Sumerian King List were in units and fractions of shar (3,600 years) and totaled 67 shar or 241,200 years.[8]

In the only ten-king tablet recension of this list three kings (Alalngar, [...]kidunnu, and En-men-dur-ana) are recorded as having reigned 72,000 years each.[9][10] The major recension assigns 43,200 years to the reign of En-men-lu-ana, and 36,000 years each to those of Alalngar and Dumuzid.[8]

Biblical longevity
Name Age LXX
Methuselah 969 969
Jared 962 962
Noah 950 950
Eve 940? 940?
Adam 930 930
Seth 912 912
Kenan 910 910
Enos 905 905
Mahalalel 895 895
Lamech 777 753
Shem 600 600
Eber 464 404
Cainan 460
Arpachshad 438 465
Salah 433 466
Enoch 365 365
Peleg 239 339
Reu 239 339
Serug 230 330
Job 210? 210?
Terah 205 205
Isaac 180 180
Abraham 175 175
Nahor 148 304
Jacob 147 147
Esau 147? 147?
Ishmael 137 137
Levi 137 137
Amram 137 137
Kohath 133 133
Laban 130+ 130+
Deborah 130+ 130+
Jehoiada 130 130
Sarah 127 127
Miriam 125+ 125+
Aaron 123 123
Rebecca 120+ 120+
Moses 120 120
Joseph 110 110
Joshua 110 110

Hebrew Bible

In the Hebrew Bible, the Torah, Joshua, Job, and 2 Chronicles claim several individuals with long lifespans.

Some literary critics explain these extreme ages as ancient mistranslations that converted the word "month" to "year", mistaking lunar cycles for solar ones: this would turn an age of 969 "years" into a more reasonable 969 lunar months, or 78½ years of the Metonic cycle.[11] However, the text says that Arpachshad (son of Shem) fathered Shelah at 35 years of age. If that is taken to mean 35 months, then Arpachshad was a father before turning three years of age — which is clearly impossible. In addition, the first chapters of Genesis distinguish solar cycles of years from lunar cycles of months. (Genesis 1:14-16; 7:11)[12]

Donald Etz says that the Genesis 5 numbers were multiplied by ten by a later editor.[13] These interpretations introduce an inconsistency as the ages of the first nine patriarchs at fatherhood, ranging from 62 to 230 years in the manuscripts, would then be transformed into an implausible range such as 5 to 18½ years.[14] Others say that the first list, of only 10 names for 1,656 years, may contain generational gaps, which would have been represented by the lengthy lifetimes attributed to the patriarchs.[10] Nineteenth-century critic Vincent Goehlert suggests the lifetimes "represented epochs merely, to which were given the names of the personages especially prominent in such epochs, who, in consequence of their comparatively long lives were able to acquire an exalted influence."[15]

Biblical scholars that assert literal translation give explanations for the advanced ages of the early patriarchs. In one view man was originally to have everlasting life, but as sin was introduced into the world by Adam and Eve, its influence became greater with each generation and God progressively shortened man's life. The Biblical upper limit of longevity was categorized by the Bible scholar Witness Lee as having four successive plateaus of 1,000, 500, 250, and finally 120 years,[16] and "four falls of mankind" correspond to these four plateaus.[17] In a second view, before Noah's flood, a "firmament" over the earth (Genesis 1:6–8) contributed to people's advanced ages.[18]

Persian empire

The reigns of several shahs in the Shahnameh, an epic poem by Ferdowsi, are given as longer than a century:

China

Lucian wrote about the "Seres" (a Chinese people), claiming they lived for over 300 years.

Japan

Some early emperors of Japan ruled for more than a century, according to the tradition documented in the Kojiki, viz., Emperor Jimmu and Emperor Kōan.

Korea

Roman empire

In Roman times, Pliny wrote about longevity records from the census carried out in 74 AD under Vespasian. In one region of Italy many people allegedly lived past 100; four were said to be 130, others even older. The ancient Greek author Lucian is the presumed author of Macrobii (long-livers), a work devoted to longevity. Most of the examples Lucian gives are what would be regarded as normal long lifespans (80–100 years).

Poland

Christianity

Islam

Hinduism

Buddhist saints

Falun Gong

Theosophy/New Age

Political claims

China
United Kingdom
United States of America

Social Security: In the Social Security Death Index, the extreme age claim is of Anne Feinseth from New Jersey. She claimed to have been born February 12, 1809 and died February 24, 2004 at the alleged age of 195 years (ssn:135-42-7235). Elizabeth M. Mahony of California claimed birth on October 28, 1808, and died March 13, 2000 at the claimed age of 191 years, according to her death certificate.[48]

Hungary
Pakistan

The 1973 National Geographic article on longevity also reported, as a very aged people, the Burusho or Hunza people in the Hunza Valley of the mountains of Pakistan.[52]

Russia (Soviet Union)

Deaths officially reported in Russia in 1815 listed 1068 centenarians, including 246 supercentenarians (50 at age 120–155 and one even older).[27] Time magazine considered that, by the Soviet Union, longevity had elevated to a state-supported "Methuselah cult".[7] The USSR insisted on its citizens' unrivaled longevity by claiming 592 people (224 male, 368 female) over age 120 in a 15 January 1959 census[53] and 100 citizens of Russia alone ages 120 to 156 in March 1960.[4] Such later claims were fostered by Georgian-born Joseph Stalin's apparent hope that he would live long past 70.[7] Zhores A. Medvedev, who demonstrated that all 500-plus claims failed birth-record validation and other tests,[7] said Stalin "liked the idea that [other] Georgians lived to be 100".[4]

South Africa
Sweden

Swedish death registers contain detailed information on thousands of centenarians going back to 1749; the maximum age at death reported between 1751 and 1800 was 127.[57]

Switzerland

Swiss anatomist Albrecht von Haller collected examples of 62 people ages 110–120, 29 ages 120–130, and 15 ages 130–140.[59]

Turkey

Practices

Diets

The Okinawa diet has some reputation of linkage to exceptionally high ages.[62] The traditional Okinawan lifestyle that may have promoted longevity has now been lost, and men from Okinawa are no longer the longest-lived in Japan, although women from the region still are.[63]

Alchemy

Traditions that have been believed to confer greater human longevity include alchemy.[3] Nicolas Flamel (early 1330s – 1418?) was a 14th-century scrivener who developed a reputation as alchemist and creator of an "elixir of life" that conferred immortality upon himself and his wife Perenelle. His arcanely inscribed tombstone is preserved at the Musée de Cluny in Paris.

Fountain of Youth

The Fountain of Youth reputedly restores the youth of anyone who drinks of its waters. The New Testament, following older Jewish tradition, attributes healing to the Pool of Bethesda when the waters are "stirred" by an angel.[67] Herodotus attributes exceptional longevity to a fountain in the land of the Ethiopians.[68] The lore of the Alexander Romance and of Al-Khidr describes such a fountain, and stories about the philosopher's stone, universal panaceas, and the elixir of life are widespread.

After the death of Juan Ponce de León, Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo wrote in Historia General y Natural de las Indias (1535) that Ponce de León was looking for the waters of Bimini to cure his aging.[69]

See also

Gallery

References

  1. ^ a b c Ni, Maoshing (2006). Secrets of Longevity. Chronicle Books. ISBN 9780811849494. http://books.google.com/?id=01GzLB2ta3oC&pg=PA101&dq=%22longevity+tradition%22. "Chuan xiong ... has long been a key herb in the longevity tradition of China, prized for its powers to boost the immune system, activate blood circulation, and relieve pain." 
  2. ^ a b c Fulder, Stephen (1983). An End to Ageing: Remedies for Life. Destiny Books. ISBN 9780892810444. http://books.google.com/?id=ABTO93imwQwC&pg=PA27&dq=%22longevity+tradition%22. "Taoist devotion to immortality is important to us for two reasons. The techniques may be of considerable value to our goal of a healthy old age, if we can understand and adapt them. Secondly, the Taoist longevity tradition has brought us many interesting remedies." 
  3. ^ a b c Kohn, Livia (2001). Daoism and Chinese Culture. Three Pines Press. pp. 4, 84. ISBN 9781931483001. http://books.google.com/?id=2AURAQAAIAAJ&q=%22longevity+tradition%22&dq=%22longevity+tradition%22. 
  4. ^ a b c Guinness Book of World Records. 1983. pp. 16–19. 
  5. ^ News Review. 1938-12-22.  In Custance, Arthur C., Ph.D. (1976). The Virgin Birth and the Incarnation. http://www.custance.org/Library/Volume5/Part_I/chapter1.html. 
  6. ^ Vallin, Jacques; Meslé, France (February 2001). "Living Beyond the Age of 100". Bulletin Mensuel d'Information de l'Institut National d'Etudes Demographiques: Population & Sociétés (Institut National d'Etudes Demographiques) (365). http://www.ined.fr/fichier/t_publication/27/publi_pdf2_pop_and_soc_english_365.pdf. 
  7. ^ a b c d "No Methuselahs". Time Magazine. 1974-08-12. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,908667-1,00.html. Retrieved 2009-05-13. 
  8. ^ a b Jacobson, Thorkild (1939). The Sumerian King List. University of Chicago Press. pp. 69–77. 
  9. ^ Hasel, Gerhard F. (1978). "The Genealogies of Gen. 5 and 11 and Their Alleged Babylonian Background". Andrews University Seminary Studies (Andrews University Press) 16: 366–7.  Citing Finkelstein, J. J. (1963). "The Antediluvian Kings: A University of California Tablet". Journal of Cuneiform Studies 17 (2): 39–51. doi:10.2307/1359063. JSTOR 1359063. 
  10. ^ a b "Notes on Genesis 5:5". Zondervan NIV Study Bible. 2002. pp. 12–13. "Three kings in a Sumerian list (which also contains exactly ten names) are said to have reigned 72,000 years each." 
  11. ^ Hill, Carol A. (2003-12-04). "Making Sense of the Numbers of Genesis". Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 55: 239. 
  12. ^ Watchtower.org
  13. ^ Etz, Donald V. (1994). "The Numbers of Genesis V 3–31: A Suggested Conversion and Its Implications". Vetus Testamentum 43 (2): 171–87. doi:10.1163/156853393X00034. 
  14. ^ Morris, Henry M. (1976). The Genesis Record: A Scientific and Devotional Commentary on the Book of Beginnings. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House. p. 159. "Such an interpretation would have made Enoch only five years old when his son was born!" 
  15. ^ Goehlert, Vincent (November 1887). "Statistical Observations upon Biblical Data" (in English). The Old Testament Student (Chicago: University of Chicago Press) 7 (3): 76–83. doi:10.1086/469948. 
  16. ^ Lee, Witness (1987). Life-Study of Genesis. II. pp. 227, 287, 361, 481. 
  17. ^ Pilch, John J. (1999). The Cultural Dictionary of the Bible. Liturgical Press. pp. 144–146. 
  18. ^ Vail, Isaac Newton (1902). The Waters Above the Firmament: Or The Earth's Annular System. Ferris and Leach. p. 97. 
  19. ^ Li, Mengyu (2008). "The Unique Values of Chinese Traditional Cultural Time Orientation: In Comparison with Western Cultural Time Orientation". The University of Rhode Island. http://www.uri.edu/iaics/content/2008v17n1/07%20Mengyu%20Li.pdf. Retrieved 2010-03-19. 
  20. ^ Aston, William (1896). Nihongi. K. Paul, Trench, Trübner. pp. 109–137. http://books.google.com/?id=1IJrNAKBpycC&pg=RA1-PA446&dq=ashton+nihongi#PPA109,M1. 
  21. ^ Yang, S. C. The South and North Korean political systems: A comparative analysis (rev. ed.). Seoul: Hollym. ISBN 1565911059. 
  22. ^ "Epimenides". Encyclopaedia Britannica. 8. Henry G. Allen. 1890. p. 482. http://books.google.com/?id=6SaalkfxgkAC&pg=PA482&lpg=PA482&dq=epimenides+%22nearly+three+hundred+years%22#v=onepage&q=epimenides%20%22nearly%20three%20hundred%20years%22&f=false. 
  23. ^ a b c d Prichard, James C. (1836). Researches into the Physical History of Mankind. 1. London: Houlston and Stoneman. pp. 11–5 ff. http://www.custance.org/Library/Volume5/Part_I/chapter1.html. 
  24. ^ Lichtenberger, Frédéric, ed. (1881). Encyclopédie des sciences religieuses. 11. Sandoz et Fischbacher. p. 570. http://books.google.com/?id=PzxDxAUc0xoC&pg=PA570&lpg=PA570&dq=%22mort+de+saint+Servais%22+%2213+mai%22#v=onepage&q=%22mort%20de%20saint%20Servais%22%20%2213%20mai%22&f=false. 
  25. ^ Calvert, Kenneth (October 1999). Ascetic Agitators. Christian History. p. 28. http://www.christianitytoday.com/ch/1999/issue64/64h028.html?start=2. 
  26. ^ Coptic Orthodox Church Network (2005). "Commemorations for Abib 7". St. Mark Coptic Church. http://www.copticchurch.net/synaxarium/11_7.html. 
  27. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Hulbert, Charles (1825). "Instances of Human Longevity in Europe". Museum Europæum; or, Select antiquities ... of nature and art, in Europe. pp. 451–7. 
  28. ^ Thompson, Phyllis (2005). Sadhu Sundar Singh: A Biography of the Remarkable Indian Disciple of Jesus. Armour Publishing. pp. 77, 80–3. ISBN 9789814138550. http://books.google.com/?id=G5-cwrn-SBcC&pg=PA80&lpg=PA80&dq=%22sadhu+sundar+singh%22+hermit+300#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  29. ^ "Scolastica Oliveri". http://www.grg.org/CalmentFraud.html. 
  30. ^ al-Kittani, Abdul Hayye (1888–1962). Fahres-ul-Faharis wal Athbat. 2. p. 928.  In "Chains of Narration" (PDF). Minhaj-al-Quran International (UK). 2006. http://www.minhajuk.org/pdf/ijazat.pdf. 
  31. ^ Daczynski, Vincent J. (2004). "Paranormal Phenomenon: Amazing Human Abilities". http://www.amazingabilities.com/amaze7a.html. 
  32. ^ a b c McDermott, Rachel Fell (2001). Mother of My Heart, Daughter of My Dreams. Oxford University Press. p. 145. ISBN 9780195134353. http://books.google.com/?id=2PrChFaXgf0C&pg=PA145. 
  33. ^ Varishthananda, Swami (November 2007). "Varanasi: The City of Saints, Sages, and Savants" (PDF). Prabuddha Bharata (Awakened India) 112 (11): 632–3. http://www.advaitaashrama.org/pb_archive/2007/PB_2007_November.pdf. 
  34. ^ Medhasananda, Swami (2003). Varanasi At the Crossroads. Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture. p. 1042. ISBN 8187332182. 
  35. ^ "慧昭 (526–815)". http://tieba.baidu.com/f?kz=813594838. 
  36. ^ a b Li Hongzhi (April 2001). "Falun Gong". Falun Gong (4th trans. ed.). http://www.falundafa.org/book/eng/flg_2.htm. 
  37. ^ Crème, Benjamin Maitreya’s Mission Amsterdam:1997 Share International Foundation Page 680
  38. ^ "Li Ching-Yun Dead; Gave His Age As 197". The New York Times. 6 May 1933. http://www.martialdevelopment.com/blog/li-ching-yuen-the-amazing-250-year-old-man/. 
  39. ^ "Tortoise-Pigeon-Dog". Time Magazine. 1933-05-15. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,745510,00.html. Retrieved 2009-05-15. 
  40. ^ "The amazing story of master Li Ching-Yuen". http://www.tienshan.net/benefits.html. 
  41. ^ a b Thornbury, Walter (1878). "Shoreditch". Old and New London. 2. Centre for Metropolitan History. pp. 194–195. http://www.british-history.ac.uk/report.aspx?compid=45090. 
  42. ^ "Age Validation of Centenarians in the Luxdorph Gallery". Validation of Exceptional Longevity. Odense Monographs on Population Aging. 6. Jeune, Bernard, and Vaupel, James W., eds., Petersen, L.-L. B., and Jeune, Bernard, contribs. Odense University Press. 1999. http://www.demogr.mpg.de/books/odense/6/03.htm. 
  43. ^ Thoms, William J. (1979) [1873]. Human Longevity: Its Facts and Its Fictions (reprint ed.). London; New York City: John Murray; Arno Press. p. 287. 
  44. ^ Marden, Orison Swett (2003) [1921]. The Secret of Achivement. Kessinger Publishing. p. 228. http://books.google.com/books?id=Xckgkomy-ToC&pg=PA228#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  45. ^ Krünitz, Johann Georg (1806). Oekonomisch-technologische Encyklopädie oder allgemeines System der Stats-, Stadt-, Haus- und Landwirthschaft und der Kunst-Geschichte. 66. Pauli. p. 764. http://books.google.com/books?id=6_06AAAAcAAJ&pg=PA764#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  46. ^ Wright, Geoffrey N. (1996). Discovering Epitaphs. Osprey Publishing. pp. 25–6. http://books.google.com/books?id=D-QaQQjKMgcC&pg=PA25#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  47. ^ Wiseman, Nicholas Patrick (February–May 1862). "The Old Countess of Desmond". The Dublin Review (London: Thomas Richardson and Son) 51: 78. http://books.google.co.uk/books?vid=05Yjnroz9rr3sL7hhv&id=xWnqaPtA0AoC&pg=PA51&printsec=4&dq=%22dublin+review%22&as_brr=1#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  48. ^ "Social Security Death Index". http://ssdi.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/ssdi.cgi. Retrieved 2011-03-28. 
  49. ^ http://immortalityresearchcenter.com/veryold/ColesteinVeglin615.pdf
  50. ^ http://immortalityresearchcenter.com/index_files/downloads.htm
  51. ^ a b Demogr.mpg.de
  52. ^ a b Leaf, Alexander (January 1973). "Search for the Oldest People". National Geographic: pp. 93–118. 
  53. ^ Vestnik Statistiki. Statistical Herald. April 1961. 
  54. ^ Garson, Lea Keil (July 1991). "The Centenarian Question: Old-Age Mortality in the Soviet Union, 1897 to 1970". Population Studies (Population Investigation Committee) 45 (2): 265–278. http://www.jstor.org/pss/2174783. 
  55. ^ Novosti Press Agency (1970). "Very Old People in the USSR". The Gerontologist 10 (2): 151–152. 
  56. ^ "Muntengwa - oldest citizen in the country". http://www.observer.co.za/stories/muntengwa-oldest-citizen-country. Retrieved 2011=03-24. 
  57. ^ Lundström, Hans; Castanova, V. (March 2000). Record Longevity in Swedish Cohorts Born Since 1700. http://www.demogr.mpg.de/Papers/Books/Monograph2/record.htm. 
  58. ^ Leksand F:1 1668-1691 p. 77
  59. ^ Dunglison, Robley (1851). Medical Lexicon: A Dictionary of Medical Science. Blanchard & Lea. p. 525. http://books.google.com/books?id=Dwe6AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA525#v=onepage&q&f=false. 
  60. ^ News.ebru.tv
  61. ^ BBC.co.uk
  62. ^ Willcox, Willcox, and Suzuki. The Okinawa program: Learn the secrets to healthy longevity. p. 3. 
  63. ^ Oya Yusuke, University Ryukyus; Fukiyama Koshiro, Japan Seaman Relief Association (2004). "Longevity myth in Okinawa–the Past and Present". Clinic All-round 53 (8): pp. 2245–8. ISSN 0371-1900. http://sciencelinks.jp/j-east/article/200421/000020042104A0614779.php. 
  64. ^ a b Ferguson, John (1906). Bibliotheca chemica. Glasgow: James Maclehose and Sons. p. 351. http://books.google.com/?id=RXzQAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA351&lpg=PA351&dq=Friederich+GUALDUS. Retrieved 2010-09-12. 
  65. ^ Gualdus, Friederich (1989) [1720]. Revelation of the True Chemical Wisdom (Alchemy). Muller, Leone, trans. Restoration of Alchemical Manuscripts Society. http://www.rexresearch.com/alchemy3/gualdus.htm. Retrieved 2010-09-12. 
  66. ^ Hally, René. "Tschoudy, Théodore Henry de Metz". http://sog1.free.fr/ArtHally200Tschoudy.htm. Retrieved 2010-09-12. 
  67. ^ John 5:4.
  68. ^ Herodotus, Book III: 22–4.
  69. ^ Fernández de Oviedo, Gonzalo. Historia General y Natural de las Indias, book 16, chapter XI.

Bibliography